Colleges and universities have always faced enrollment challenges. But what happens when the students you’ve traditionally counted on start disappearing from the pipeline? For many institutions, the answer starts with a sharper higher education value proposition.
According to recent reporting by Signal Ohio, five major Ohio universities saw international student enrollment fall by 11% to 32.5% this fall. Cleveland State University saw the steepest decline. Case Western Reserve University, Kent State University, the University of Cincinnati and Ohio State University all reported double-digit drops. Closer to home, Ideastream Public Media reported that overall enrollment at Cleveland State and Kent State fell about 5%. Both schools attribute the drop largely to fewer international students.
The trend extends nationally, too, and the impact goes well beyond enrollment numbers. International students contribute tuition revenue, support research, enrich campus communities and help build regional workforces. Losing even a portion of that population can have significant consequences for an institution’s financial health and long-term plans.
The reasons behind these declines are complicated and, too often, political. Immigration policies, visa challenges and uncertainty about studying in the United States are influencing decisions in ways university leaders can’t directly control. No amount of marketing is going to change that.
At TWIST, we see a consistent pattern: institutions that know exactly whom they serve and why it matters are better equipped to adapt when the market shifts. So the situation raises a question worth asking:
When the students you’ve traditionally relied on become harder to reach, how compelling is your institution’s story to everyone else?
More recruitment isn’t always the answer
When enrollment numbers soften, the natural response is to find more prospective students. Expand the geographic reach. Invest in additional advertising. Pursue new audiences. Generate more inquiries. Those efforts may be prudent, but they don’t necessarily address the underlying challenge.
Higher education is changing in ways that extend well beyond international enrollment. Demographic shifts are reshaping traditional recruiting markets. Families are asking harder questions about affordability and return on investment (ROI). Adult learners are weighing the value of a degree against other paths to career advancement. Mountains of student loan debt are making trade schools, vocational certifications and learn-on-the-job apprenticeships more attractive.
Prospective students have more options, more information and more reasons to question whether a particular institution is right for them. In that environment, simply reaching more people with the same message may not produce better results. Before asking how to attract more students, institutions should ask something more fundamental: Why should those students choose us in the first place? It’s a simple question. But answering it well requires more than a new campaign.
Your higher education value proposition: what makes you worth choosing?
Visit enough college websites and you’ll start to notice something. Different schools often sound remarkably alike.
Academic excellence. Dedicated faculty. Personalized experiences. Career readiness. A welcoming community.
These are all important qualities. They’re also promises that nearly every institution makes. The problem isn’t that these claims are necessarily untrue. It’s that they rarely give a prospective student a clear reason to choose one institution over another. A meaningful higher education value proposition goes beyond describing what a school offers. It connects what makes that institution distinctive to what its prospective students actually care about. And different students care about (many) different things.
A graduate student might prioritize research opportunities, specialized expertise or connections to industry. A working professional may be more interested in flexibility, practical skills and a clear return on the investment. A first-generation undergraduate might be looking for academic support, affordability and confidence that they’ll belong and succeed.
An institution doesn’t need to try to become something different for every audience, or even something for all audiences. But it does need to understand which of its own strengths matter most to the people it’s most trying to reach. That’s the difference between having a collection of selling points and having a clear, compelling position in the market.
The answers might surprise you
One of the biggest mistakes institutions can make is assuming they already know why students choose them. University leaders understandably have strong opinions about what makes their institutions special. Faculty see value through the lens of academic excellence. Admissions teams get the most direct feedback about what resonates in recruitment conversations. Marketing departments work to understand and weave all of those perspectives together. But those internal perspectives don’t always align with what students actually value.
And when enrollment patterns change, the gap between what an institution believes about itself and what prospective students believe can become a real liability. This is where research, listening and honest assessment become essential. Why do students enroll? Why do others choose a competitor? What do current students value most about their experience? Which academic programs, partnerships or outcomes offer a meaningful advantage? And are those strengths showing up clearly in the institution’s marketing?
Sometimes the most compelling differentiator isn’t the one leadership has been emphasizing.
It might be an unusually strong connection to regional employers. A distinctive approach to experiential learning. A particular academic program with exceptional outcomes. Or a student support system that delivers on promises other institutions merely make. Consider a hypothetical regional university that assumes its rankings are its biggest draw. Research reveals something different: students choose it for its co-op placements with local employers, and graduates credit those placements for landing their first jobs. That insight could reshape how the university speaks to working adults and transfer students, and where it invests its recruitment budget.
The point isn’t to invent a better story; it’s to uncover the strongest one you already have, understand who will find it meaningful, and tell it with greater clarity and conviction.
Clarity is a competitive advantage
No institution can control every factor affecting enrollment. International student mobility, demographics, economic conditions and changing expectations will continue to shape the market.
But institutions can control how well they understand their audiences, how clearly they define their value and how consistently they communicate it.
That clarity does more than improve marketing. It helps enrollment teams focus their efforts, gives academic leaders a stronger framework for evaluating opportunities and helps institutions make smarter decisions about where to invest limited resources.
It also creates flexibility. When circumstances change, an institution with a clear understanding of its strengths can adapt how it reaches and engages different audiences without constantly reinventing its identity.
Clarity also makes results easier to measure: track applications, yield and enrolled students alongside inquiries and website traffic. More leads from the wrong audience aren’t an enrollment result.
The answer isn’t necessarily to spend more, cast a wider net or chase every potential new audience. And it certainly isn’t to assume that better messaging alone can overcome forces beyond an institution’s control.
It’s to take a harder look at what makes your institution genuinely valuable, who stands to benefit most from that value and whether you’re making a compelling case for choosing you. That’s where TWIST helps: uncovering what students actually value, identifying where messaging falls short and defining a position worth choosing.
Because when the student pipeline changes, the strength of your higher education value proposition matters more than ever.
Ready to sharpen your institution’s story? Schedule a conversation with TWIST.

About the Author
Adam Zuccaro, Director of Client Partnership at TWIST Creative, brings decades of experience guiding organizations in building high-performance marketing programs. A dynamic strategist, he aligns vision, sharpens execution, and drives measurable growth.